|
|
||||||||
Physiological Reviews, Vol. 82, No. 2, April 2002, pp. 473-502; 10.1152/physrev.00031.2001.
Copyright ©2002 by the American Physiological Society
Section of Protein Engineering, Laboratory of Molecular Endocrinology, Medical Biotechnology Center, University of Maryland Biotechnology Institute, Baltimore, Maryland; and Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Marseille, France
I. INTRODUCTION
II. HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF THYROID-STIMULATING HORMONE AND THYROID-STIMULATING HORMONE RECEPTOR RESEARCH
III. THYROID-STIMULATING HORMONE CHEMISTRY AND MOLECULAR BIOLOGY
A. TSH Subunit Genes
B. TSH Structure
C. TSH Heterogeneity
IV. THYROID-STIMULATING HORMONE STRUCTURE-FUNCTION STUDIES
A. Methodology
B. Studies of Protein Domains
C. Naturally Occurring hTSH-Subunit Mutations
D. Function of Carbohydrate Chains
E. Alterations of TSH Carbohydrates Structures in Pathophysiology
V. THYROID-STIMULATING HORMONE RECEPTOR AND THYROID-STIMULATING HORMONE-THYROID-STIMULATING HORMONE RECEPTOR INTERACTION
A. TSHR: Gene and Expression
B. TSHR Structure-Function Studies
C. Naturally Occurring TSHR Mutations
D. Suppressive Effect of Extracellular Domain: The "Two-State" Model
E. Other Concepts of TSH-TSHR Interaction
F. Electrostatic Forces in the TSH-TSHR Interaction
G. Evolutionary Adaptation of TSH Bioactivity
H. Relationship to Other CKGF
VI. RECOMBINANT THYROID-STIMULATING HORMONE AND ITS ANALOGS
A. Applications of rhTSH
B. Design of TSH Analogs
C. Perspectives in the Engineering of TSH, Gonadotropins, and Other CKGFs
VII. NEW CONCEPTS AND TECHNOLOGIES
VIII. PERSPECTIVES AND CLOSING COMMENTARY
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Szkudlinski, Mariusz W.,
Valerie Fremont,
Catherine Ronin, and
Bruce D. Weintraub.
Thyroid-Stimulating Hormone and Thyroid-Stimulating Hormone
Receptor Structure-Function Relationships. Physiol. Rev. 82: 473-502, 2002; 10.1152/physrev.00031.2001.
This review focuses on recent advances in
the structure-function relationships of thyroid-stimulating
hormone (TSH) and its receptor. TSH is a member of the glycoprotein
hormone family constituting a subset of the cystine-knot growth
factor superfamily. TSH is produced by the pituitary thyrotrophs and
released to the circulation in a pulsatile manner. It stimulates
thyroid functions using specific membrane TSH receptor (TSHR) that
belongs to the superfamily of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs).
New insights into the structure-function relationships of TSH
permitted better understanding of the role of specific protein and
carbohydrate domains in the synthesis, bioactivity, and clearance of
this hormone. Recent progress in studies on TSHR as well as studies on
the other GPCRs provided new clues regarding the molecular mechanisms
of receptor activation. Such advances are a result of extensive
site-directed mutagenesis, peptide and antibody approaches,
detailed sequence analyses, and molecular modeling as well as studies
on naturally occurring gain- and loss-of-function mutations. This
review integrates expanding information on TSH and TSHR
structure-function relationships and summarizes current concepts on
ligand-dependent and -independent TSHR activation. Special emphasis
has been placed on TSH domains involved in receptor recognition,
constitutive activity of TSHR, new insights into the evolution of TSH
bioactivity, and the development of high-affinity TSH analogs. Such
structural, physiological, pathophysiological, evolutionary, and
therapeutic implications of TSH-TSHR structure-function studies are
frequently discussed in relation to concomitant progress made in
studies on gonadotropins and their receptors.
| |
I. INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH; thyrotropin) and TSH receptor
(TSHR) are key proteins in the control of thyroid function. TSH
synthesis in the anterior pituitary is stimulated by
thyrotropin-releasing hormone (TRH) and inhibited by thyroid
hormone in a classical endocrine negative-feedback loop. TSH
controls thyroid function upon its interaction with the G
protein-coupled TSHR (215). TSH binding to its
receptor on thyroid cells leads to the stimulation of second messenger
pathways involving predominantly cAMP and, in high concentrations,
inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate (IP3) and diacylglycerol
(DAG), ultimately resulting in the modulation of thyroidal gene
expression. Physiological roles of TSH include stimulation of
differentiated thyroid functions, such as iodine uptake and
organification, production and release of iodothyronines from the gland, and promotion of thyroid growth. TSH also acts as a
factor protecting thyroid cells from apoptosis and plays a critical
role in ontogeny. In a mouse model with targeted disruption of the
common
-subunit gene and thus devoid circulating glycoprotein hormones, thyroid development was arrested in late gestation
(93).
| |
II. HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF THYROID-STIMULATING HORMONE AND THYROID-STIMULATING HORMONE RECEPTOR RESEARCH |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The history of TSH began with the discovery of
thyroid-stimulating activity in the pituitary gland. In 1926 Eduard
Uhlenhuth from the University of Maryland Medical School was the first
to demonstrate that the anterior lobe of the pituitary gland secreted a
thyroid stimulator (209). Using several species of
salamanders (amphibians) he showed that injections of bovine pituitary
extracts caused a clear histological stimulation of the thyroid gland. In 1929, Leo Loeb and Max Aaron working independently confirmed Uhlenhuth's results using guinea pigs (mammals). These initial findings were followed in the 1960s by the purification and in the
early 1970s by the determination of the primary structure of the TSH
subunits (114). In the 1980s, the cloning of the human
-subunit (52) and TSH
-subunit genes
(72, 77, 223) were important
milestones in studying TSH expression, regulation, and action. From the
basic science standpoint, another major breakthrough occurred in 1994 with the elucidation of the crystal structure of the closely related
human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) (103, 226), which indicated that the glycoprotein hormones
belong to the superfamily of cystine-knot growth factors (CKGF). It
also enabled the generation of homology models of human TSH (hTSH) that
combined with homology comparisons and identification of modification
permissive residues in the peripheral loops resulted in 1994 in the
generation of the first hTSH superactive analogs (191).
Thirty-five years ago it was found that TSH exerts its biological effects by binding to a protein on the thyroid cell plasma membrane (152). Subsequent milestones included studies showing that 1) TSHR is a major thyroid autoantigen, 2) TSHR can be stimulated or inhibited by specific antibodies, and 3) TSHR is composed of two subunits as a result of its proteolytic cleavage (for reviews see Refs. 135, 159). Following the molecular cloning and sequencing of luteinizing hormone (LH) receptor cDNA (111, 122), several groups reported cloning and functional expression of TSHR cDNA (2, 55, 85, 108, 109, 127, 134, 149). These advances initiated a period of rapid progress in studies on TSHR.
| |
III. THYROID-STIMULATING HORMONE CHEMISTRY AND MOLECULAR BIOLOGY |
|---|
|
|
|---|
TSH is a 28- to 30-kDa glycoprotein synthesized and secreted from
thyrotrophs (basophile cells) of the anterior pituitary gland. It is a
member of the glycoprotein hormone family that includes
follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH), LH, and hCG. Glycoprotein hormones are among the largest and most complicated endocrine ligands
known to date. They are heterodimeric cystine-knot glycoproteins consisting of a common
-subunit and a unique
-subunit, which confers biological specificity to each hormone (103,
155).
A. TSH Subunit Genes
The common human
-subunit and TSH
-subunit are encoded by
genes located on chromosomes 6 and 1, respectively (42).
The organization of the human
-subunit and TSH
-subunit genes is shown in Figure 1. The
-subunit gene
contains four exons and three introns, whereas the TSH
-subunit gene
contains three exons and two introns. The
-subunit gene is almost
two times larger (9.4 kb) than the TSH
-subunit gene (4.9 kb). The
first exon is short in both cases, untranslated, and separated from the
coding region by a large first intron. Each gene contains a single
transcription start site with an upstream TATA box that binds RNA
polymerase II. In contrast to more general expression of
-subunit
gene, TSH
-subunit gene expression in the anterior pituitary is
restricted to thyrotroph cells, which constitute ~5% of all
adenohypophysial cells. The concomitant progress made in understanding
the regulation of the
- and TSH
-subunit genes is not discussed
here, because this topic has been covered in detail in many papers and
several excellent review articles and chapters (25,
177, 221, 225).
|
B. TSH Structure
1. Protein structure
hTSH consists of two noncovalently linked subunits,
-subunit
(92 amino acids; common for other human glycoprotein hormones) and TSH
-subunit. The primary structures (see Fig.
2) of TSH subunits are species specific.
hTSH, for example, differs from bovine TSH by 28 amino acids in the
-subunit and by 12 amino acids in TSH
-subunit. The coding
sequence of the TSH
-subunit gene predicts a 118-amino acid protein
(223). However,
-subunit of TSH isolated from cadaver
pituitary is composed of 112 amino acids (155), most
likely due to proteolytic cleavage during purification. A 113- to
118-amino acid deletion does not affect bioactivity of recombinant
hTSH, indicating that the COOH-terminal amino acid residues are not
important in hormone function (198).

View larger version (11K):
[in a new window]
Fig. 2.
The primary structure of the human
-subunit (A) and
the human TSH (hTSH)
-subunit (B). Functionally important
residues are numbered and highlighted in boldface in the wild-type
sequence. Specific mutations are shown either above the corresponding
wild-type residue (if the mutation resulted in an increase of hTSH
activity) or below (if mutation caused a decrease of activity).
Mutations
N78Q and
N23Q, which disrupt a
glycosylation recognition sequence (highlighted by the outlined font)
decrease in vivo, but not in vitro activity (see text), whereas
disruption of the glycosylation recognition sequence at
N52 (
N52Q,
N52D) increases
in vitro, but slightly decreases in vivo activity (67).
Multiple residue mutations are underlined. Also depicted is the
location of selected structural features. The
-hairpin loops
correspond to the continuous lines above the primary structure flanked
by arrows. The bold part of these lines indicates
-sheet, and the
thin part of the line indicates the actual loops.
-Helix (between
40-46) is marked with an interrupted line below the sequence (
).
The seat-belt between
C88 and
C105 is marked by a double line
(==). Chimeric substitutions in this not only decreased hTSH activity,
but also changed receptor specificity (see text). See also Figure 3 for
structural features.
TSH is a member of the glycoprotein hormone family (155),
structurally classified as part of the CKGF superfamily of structurally related proteins with important biological activities
(103, 226). The crystal structure of
homologous hCG has revealed that each subunit contains a central
cystine-knot and three loops, two
-hairpin loops (L1 and L3) on
one side of a cystine-knot, and a long loop (L2) on the other side
(see Fig. 3). The long loop in the
-subunit (
L2) contains a two-turn
-helix. The
cystine-knot is made up of three central disulfide bridges, where
one threads through a ring formed by two other disulfide bridges and
backbone atoms. This structure has previously been found in several
growth factors including platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF),
vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), transforming growth
factor-
(TGF-
), and nerve growth factor (NGF) (185)
(Table 1). In contrast to the other CKGFs
that exist as homo- or heterodimers with interchain disulfide bridges,
glycoprotein hormones are noncovalently linked heterodimers stabilized
by a unique segment of the
-subunit termed "seat-belt," because
it wraps around the
-subunit long loop (
L2). This additional
stabilization by the seat-belt results in doubling of the subunit
interface compared with the other CKGFs. This may be necessary because
of the extensive glycosylation of glycoprotein hormones, which
constitutes up to one-third of their molecular weight (Table
2). The common
-subunit and 38%
sequence identity between the hCG
- and hTSH
-subunit permitted
homology modeling of hTSH. Such homology models confirmed expected
similarities in the conformation of glycoprotein hormones
(191). Accordingly, assignment of disulfide bridges in
bovine TSH
-subunit using a double alkylation strategy revealed
bonding analogous to hCG (48). Thus, in hTSH
-subunit,
three disulfide bridges (Cys2-Cys52, Cys27-Cys83, and Cys31-Cys85) form
cystine-knot motif that determines the core structure, two
disulfide bridges (Cys19-Cys105, Cys88-Cys95) are involved in
seat-belt formation, and one (Cys17-Cys67) links two
-hairpin
loops.
|
|
|
2. Carbohydrate chains
TSH, similar to other glycoprotein hormones, is a glycosylated
protein. The carbohydrate chains constitute 15-25% of its weight and
include three asparagine (Asn; N)-linked carbohydrate
chains. The human
-subunit has two carbohydrate chains linked to
Asn-52 and Asn-78, respectively, and the human TSH
-subunit has one carbohydrate chain attached at the Asn-23. Such N-linked
oligosaccharides are complex-type structures displaying notable
hormone- and species-dependent differences in their terminal
residues. In TSH like in most glycoproteins, the inner core
fucosylation and variable glycan branching are two common forms of
N-glycan variability. Figure 4
shows typical biantennary structures of pituitary bovine TSH (bTSH)
terminated almost exclusively with
SO4-4GalNAc
1-4GlcNAc
1-2R, pituitary human TSH
(phTSH) oligosaccharides terminated with
SO4-4GalNAc
1-4GlcNAc
1-2R, but also with
NeuAc
2-3/6Gal
1-4GlcNAc
1-2R and recombinant human TSH
(rhTSH) expressed in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells containing only NeuAc
2-3Gal
1-4GlcNAc
1-2R terminal sequences
(188). Pituitary TSH and LH are unique in that they
contain a terminal sulfated GalNAc, due to the expression of both
GalNAc-transferase and sulfotransferase in the pituitary
thyrotrophs and gonadotrophs.
|
Several studies have assigned to each carbohydrate chain a different
role in the uncombined and combined subunits. Differently deglycosylated variants of the common
-subunit were shown to differ
in thermal stability. Glycosylation at Asn-78 appeared to be required
for the stability of the protein with the inner core interacting with
hydrophobic amino acids and reducing the mobility of the glycan not
only at the attachment site but also around the
1,6 arm
(213). This glycan has been proposed to stabilize the
hydrophobic packing of the
-sheets within the subunit and as a
consequence to affect the interaction of the modified L1 and L3 loops
with the extracellular domain of the TSHR (107, 191). Because both modified loops contribute to TSH
bioactivity, it is conceivable that such effect may influence receptor
binding and activation. In this regard, it should be noted that Asn-78 glycan is sulfated in TSH and contains a unique NeuAc
2,6 linkage in
LH. In contrast to Asn-78, the glycan at Asn-52 in the
-subunit L2
loop was found to be highly mobile in the free subunit, but its
mobility in the heterodimer is restricted by the seat-belt (80). It is known that the region
33-57 is largely
involved in signal transduction and significantly altered by subunit
dissociation. According to Erbel et al. (47), comparison
of X-ray structures of intact deglycosylated hCG and NMR structure
of
-subunit in solution revealed that the dissociation of the
hormone dimer induces large structural changes in the
-subunit,
resulting in increased mobility of the glycan at Asn-52. Recently also,
the structure of intact and deglycosylated hCG in complex with two
Fv fragments of high-affinity anti-
and anti-
monoclonal antibodies has been solved. Fv fragment of an antibody is
the smallest unit that contains complete antigen-binding site. The
structure of hCG in such complexes is very similar to that of the
partially deglycosylated hormone, suggesting that neither the Fv
antibodies nor the whole oligosaccharides have substantial influence on
hormone structure (201). However, these data do not
entirely agree with NMR analysis in solution; overall, the structural
data indicate that the heterodimer backbone is highly flexible to
undergo local conformational changes to acquire various active
(carbohydrate-dependent) and inactive (carbohydrate-independent) states.
C. TSH Heterogeneity
hTSH, purified from the cadaver pituitary, has been shown to be heterogeneous at the NH2 terminus of each subunit due to variable terminal truncation of both subunit polypeptide chains occurring physiologically or during purification. Presence of shortened isoforms of circulating TSH may affect interaction with antibodies binding at the COOH terminus and influence immunoassays using them. In addition, variable amidation of glutamic acid and aspartic acid residues, known to occur during prolonged storage of purified protein preparations, may introduce additional artifacts that can cause discordance in assaying TSH.
Differences in oligosaccharide structure generate a mixture of circulating isoforms (glycoforms), which represent the majority of physiological heterogeneity of hTSH. Heterogeneity of carbohydrate chains is a property shared by all glycoproteins, which appeared to be remarkably specific among glycoprotein hormones. It is based on alternate inner core fucosylation, variable oligosaccharide branching, and specific terminal GalNAc sulfation in TSH and LH. As a result, each hormone of the family has been shown to exist as a distinct set of glycoforms differing in oligosaccharide structure and bioactivity. Alterations of the bioactivity to immunoreactivity (B/I) ratio of glycoforms have been extensively studied in several pathophysiological conditions, indicating that glycosylation-dependent polymorphism of glycoprotein hormones has important physiological implications.
The detection of glycoprotein hormone isoforms is based on their respective isoelectric points using isoelectric focusing or chromatofocusing. Specific isoforms are separated on the basis of their negative charge content that for TSH is determined by a presence of both sulfated and sialic acid residues. Glycoforms of pituitary TSH ranged over pH 6.8-8.3, indicating that modification of the underlying peptide backbone should occur upon changes in glycosylation (176). Since neuraminidase treatment did not significantly affect alkaline forms, the shift observed for more acidic forms was explained by a presence or absence of terminal sialic acid residues. Human pituitary standard TSH (2ndIRP 80558) has been recently separated according to its glycan core structure. Various glycoforms selectively activating different signal transduction pathways were found (170). Desialylated (sulfated) TSH forms showed an increased B/I ratio for cAMP production while core-fucosylated glycoforms were more potent in the IP3 pathway activation. These data are in agreement with previous observations showing that alkaline TSH glycoforms are more active in vitro than acidic forms (124).
Various preparations of recombinant human TSH (rhTSH) have been produced in CHO cells under various cell culture conditions (193) and were found to differ essentially in sialic acid content, providing enough material to correlate polymorphism with biological activity. rhTSH produced in CHO cells is more highly branched than the pituitary native hormone and terminated in sialic acid. As shown in Table 3, several rhTSH glycoforms could be detected ranging from pI 6.2 to pI 8.8 depending on the amount of sialic acid in the preparation, but none of them proved to overlap with those of pitTSH. The fact that asialo-rhTSH is homogeneous at pI 8.8 confirms that sialic acid residues play a key role in determining rhTSH polymorphism.
|
Gonadotropin microheterogeneity has been also extensively studied. Pituitary LH was solved as 24 highly purified isoforms within the pI range of 7.03 to 8.98 that exhibited a wide variability in their respective capacity to stimulate rat testicular steroidogenesis (222). FSH was separated as nine isoforms within pI 4.1-7.1 (232), showing variable receptor binding activity dependent on sialic acid content. In agreement with previous studies on rhTSH isoforms (193), less acidic variants of urinary FSH exhibited higher bioactivity as tested using androgen aromatization in heterologous bioassays. In contrast, several previous studies indicated that N-linked carbohydrates are not necessary for binding to the receptor but are needed to stabilize the active conformation of glycoprotein hormone-receptor complex resulting in signal transduction (80, 169). Altogether, these findings delineate a different role of sialic acid in glycoprotein hormones with an enhancement of in vitro activity for hCG and a lowering for hTSH, hLH, and hFSH. Glycoforms are predicted to stabilize distinct receptor conformations resulting in different degrees of activation/inhibition of signal transduction pathway(s). Thus it appears that terminal glycosylation of glycoprotein hormones provides additional structural versatility to modulate signal transduction without modifying ligand recognition of the underlying polypeptide backbone and thus ligand specificity.
| |
IV. THYROID-STIMULATING HORMONE STRUCTURE-FUNCTION STUDIES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A. Methodology
Structure-function studies on glycoprotein hormones can be categorized into studies on the carbohydrate moiety as well as on the peptide portion, but these two approaches can be combined and studied simultaneously. Structure-function studies involve alteration of coding sequences using molecular biology techniques, various chemical and biochemical modifications, as well as utilization of antibodies or synthetic peptides (70). In general, each of these methods has its advantages that are balanced by inherent limitations. Initially, physicochemical and enzymatic studies have identified amino acids as well as carbohydrate portions on both subunits which contribute to dimerization of two subunits, receptor binding, and signal transduction. These approaches, which are summarized in excellent reviews (5, 14, 39, 140, 171, 187), have been instrumental in gaining an initial understanding of glycoprotein hormone structure-function relationships and continue to provide valuable information to the present time. Other valuable strategies rely primarily on epitope mapping or the use of synthetic peptides (39, 88, 94, 129).
The advent of recombinant DNA technology provided new and unique
opportunities to recognize functional domains of glycoprotein hormones.
In particular, site-directed mutagenesis has recently gained a
predominant role in such analyses. The now classical method of alanine
scanning relies on the fact that alanine is generally considered to be
the least disruptive mutation that can be made in the absence of any
specific knowledge about protein interactions. The high helical
propensity of alanine makes it especially favorable for substitution at
helical residues. This technique was recently expanded to a
proline/alanine scanning approach, taking additional advantage of the
tendency of proline to introduce bending into the polypeptide chain
(192). Specifically,
-helical structures are found to
be kinked and destabilized following the introduction of proline
residues (231), in contrast to alanine substitutions,
which tend to preserve the
-helical conformation. Therefore, in
addition to conventional alanine scanning, selective introduction of
proline constitutes a test for conformational stringency in different
areas. This approach may thus help to quickly differentiate the effect
of peptide backbone perturbations from the role of specific amino acid
side chains in protein function. In addition, such combined techniques
can lead to the recognition of "modification permissive domains,"
which allow introduction of nonconservative changes into hormones, thus
enabling modulation of function without compromising protein synthesis,
folding, and function (191). Further development of such
strategies including multiple residue replacement should be helpful to
elucidate cooperative effects of individual residues, and this can be
extended to the simultaneous mutagenesis of multiple, topically
unrelated hormone regions. With such an approach, it should ultimately
be possible to individually modulate and dissociate defined biological
properties of complex molecules such as hTSH. In fact, this strategy
led to the finding that a partial or complete loss of hTSH activity caused by modifications in one domain may in certain instances be
completely compensated by alterations in an unrelated domain (192). Such studies predict that the TSHR is capable of
tolerating ligands with significant structural modifications, by means
of an "analog-induced fit." It may therefore even be possible to create alternative contact domains of analog and receptor resulting in
signal transduction. Such plasticity of ligand-receptor
interactions is supported by the observation that the TSHR can be
constitutively activated by multiple mutations in various receptor
regions (44). Moreover, identification of cooperative,
noncooperative, and mutually exclusive hormone domains can provide
important leads for further development of therapeutically useful
hormone analogs.
Restoration of the activity of a mutant hormone analog by appropriate modifications of the receptor can also demonstrate that a mutation causes a site-specific decrease of hormone activity. Such parallel mutagenesis of ligand and receptor is a promising approach that received only scant attention so far (86). This combined strategy should allow identification of cooperative interactions of specific domains of ligand and receptor and therefore be highly informative in understanding mechanistic aspects of glycoprotein hormone signal transduction. Another newly developed powerful technique, linker scanning mutagenesis, is a method for introducing codons (peptides) into cloned DNA to select modification permissive and nonpermissive sites in the proteins they encode (6, 73).
It should be pointed out that, as with other approaches, these recombinant techniques are not free of limitations. For adequate interpretation of mutagenesis studies, possible effects of a mutation caused by aberrant subunit folding and dimerization should be considered. Such changes could result in distant conformational effects that may alter hormone function in an indirect fashion. This is especially possible if secretion, immunoreactivity, receptor binding, or bioactivity of mutated analogs is profoundly impaired. In contrast, "gain-of-function" changes, such as enhanced receptor binding or switch of hormonal specificity, are more likely to be the result of direct residue/domain-specific effects. Nevertheless, it is prudent to ascertain accurate quantitation and to rule out the possibility of global conformational changes of analogs with multiple mutations by testing them against a panel of different antibodies or by circular dichroic (CD) spectrometry.
B. Studies of Protein Domains
TSH expression and biological activity requires a noncovalent
association of
-subunit and TSH
-subunit. Free TSH
-subunit, similarly to free LH
-subunit, is degraded intracellularly, and <10% produced is secreted into the culture medium. Therefore, simultaneous coexpression of
-subunit prevents intracellular degradation of TSH
-subunit (118). The most important
domains in TSH expression and bioactivity recognized thus far are
depicted in Figure 3. Certain domains are tightly conserved among
different species or homologous hormones, and even minor modifications
of such areas result in decreased expression and/or receptor binding. Most of these domains are located in close proximity and within the
"composite binding domain" as described in hCG (103).
Particularly important domains/residues in receptor activation include
-helix (
40-46),
Lys51,
Asn52-linked oligosacharide, the
-COOH terminus (
88-92),
33-38, "the Keutmann's loop"
(TSH
31-52), and the "seat-belt" in the
-subunit (TSH
88-105) (70, 188). The seat-belt region
is critical in conferring glycoprotein hormone specificity, probably by
restricting heterologous ligand-receptor interactions and/or
influencing the conformation of the composite binding domain. Studies involving
-subunit chimeras indicated that the seat-belt is also critical for heterodimer expression and stability
(69). Functionally important residues were also identified
in studies of patients with familial hypothyroidism and natural
mutations in the TSH
-subunit gene (see below).
Several additional regions and residues have been recently recognized
to be involved in the modulation of TSH and gonadotropin function.
Studies employing the combination of alanine- and proline-scanning mutagenesis have revealed the importance of
-helical conformation (
40-46) in TSH bioactivity. Furthermore, the
11-20 region with a cluster of basic residues (K-K/R-K
K/R), present in all vertebrates except hominoids (apes and humans), has been recognized as an important
motif in the evolution of TSH and gonadotropin bioactivity in primates
(191). Importantly, the elimination of basic residues in
this region resulted in a decrease of TSH intrinsic activity and
coincided with the divergence of apes from Old World monkeys (Table
4, Fig.
5). Identification of such
nonconservative amino acid changes during hormone evolution suggested
that rapid adaptive mechanisms directed by natural selection were
involved. In addition to these evolutionary insights (see below), this
study (191) provided the first evidence that selective
alteration of residues in the loop domains to charged residues may
permit design of analogs with enhanced bioactivity. Further studies
suggested that the presence of basic amino acids in the
-subunit
sequence of L3 loop modulated intrinsic activity of TSH and
gonadotropins (Fig. 5) (66).
|
|
With regard to the role of cystine-knot motif, it is quite surprising that an intact cystine-knot structure is important only for intracellular stability and hetrodimerization of subunits, but not essential for receptor binding and bioactivity of glycoprotein hormones (82). However, as observed for several other proteins, the evolutionary pressure to maintain or optimize receptor binding sites and activation seems to be much stronger than relatively low pressure to enhance stability, which is dependent on two cystine-knot motifs and can be maintained just above a certain threshold to preserve heterodimer function. Remarkable flexibility of the glycoprotein hormones in maintaining receptor binding was supported by our "restoration of activity" strategy. We have observed that certain gain-of-function mutations can compensate for almost all "loss-of-function" mutations in hTSH and hCG (69, 192).
C. Naturally Occurring hTSH
-Subunit Mutations
Familial TSH deficiency has been described in several families
with point mutations in the TSH
-subunit gene (Table
5). In a Greek kindred described by
Dacou-Voutetakis et al. (35), a point mutation
converted a glutamic acid codon (GAA, codon 12) to a premature stop
codon (TAA). No functional TSH
-subunit was produced in patients
with two defective alleles, and TSH was not detectable in the serum.
Hayashizaki et al. (76) described several related Japanese
families with a point mutation in the CAGY region of the TSH
-subunit gene. The CAGY region (named based on the one-letter
amino acid code) is a conserved region of glycoprotein hormone
-subunit essential for
-
subunit interactions. In these kindred, codon 29 was converted from a GGA (Gly) to AGA (Arg). This
alteration prevents the mutant TSH
-subunit from interacting with
the common
-subunit, and intact TSH is not secreted from the
thyrotroph in patients containing two defective alleles. Next kindred
with a TSH
-gene point mutation was described by Medeiros-Neto et al. (123). This family had a frameshift deletion in
codon 105 resulting in premature truncation of the TSH
-subunit. TSH was detectable at low levels in the serum, but radioactive iodine scans
clearly demonstrated thyroid hypofunction in affected family members.
Hypothyroidism in this family may be due either to impaired TSH
secretion or secretion of TSH with reduced or absent biological activity. Other authors (12, 41) described
similar autosomal recessive TSH defects. In all cases, sequencing of
the entire coding region of the human TSH
-subunit gene revealed a
homozygous single base pair deletion in codon 105, resulting in a
change of a highly conserved Cys to Val followed by eight altered amino acids and a premature stop codon due to the frame-shift. It is likely that elimination of highly conserved Cys-105 causes a major conformational change in the TSH molecule. However, unlike the previous
TSH
-subunit gene mutations, immunoreactive TSH is detectable in
these patients' circulation. Because of the early development of
severe symptoms in neonatal period, it was proposed, but not proven,
that such altered TSH may suppress the physiological constitutive activity of the unliganded TSHR (12).
|
D. Function of Carbohydrate Chains
The presence of alternative GalNAc4-SO4 (and/or Gal-3-SO4) termini in LH and TSH, but not in FSH and hCG, indicates that outer glycosylation is hormone specific and raises questions regarding the role of carbohydrate termini in hormone biosynthesis and their biological significance. Deglycosylation of hCG and bovine TSH has long been known to result in increased receptor binding but loss in efficient signal transduction. Many reviews have covered the role of carbohydrate chains in glycoprotein hormone assembly, secretion, and bioactivity, and the reader is invited to refer to them for more detailed information (4, 14, 146, 188, 222). It appears that glycosylation can play a role in the life span of the hormone through different glycan structure. More recently, the work of several laboratories focused on two aspects: 1) subunit folding and 2) site-directed mutagenesis of individual glycosylation sites and their distinct roles in hormone function. We will emphasize these new developments describing studies on subunit folding and assembly, biological activity, and metabolic clearance.
1. Subunit assembly
Subunit folding and assembly are crucial intracellular events for
hormone formation, especially in view of the heterologous expression of
these hormones in host cells. Subunit folding relies on the action of
many accessory proteins including chaperone-like glucose-specific
calnexin/calreticulin and disulfide isomerase, all proteins present in
the CHO cells during biosynthesis of recombinant proteins.
Site-directed mutagenesis of cysteine residues in the hCG
-subunit revealed that disulfide bonding is a prerequisite for
subunit association and oligosaccharide assembly. It has been noticed
that folding intermediates differ in disulfide pairing from the native
dimer and that elimination of an earlier forming disulfide bond
(Cys34-Cys88, Cys9-Cys57, or Cys38-Cys90) interferes with the
completion of glycosylation. Elimination of a later disulfide bond (Cys23-Cys72, Cys93-Cys100, or Cys26-Cys110) does not influence glycan completion (128). These findings suggest that
early conformation of the hormone dimer is crucial for oligosaccharide
processing and may affect final polymorphism. Accordingly, it can be
expected that glycan structure at each glycosylation site may indeed be governed by polypeptide folding of the respective subunit as well as of
the heterodimer since the
-subunit folds in the presence of the
-subunit that exerts a chaperone-like function
(180). As a result, the final glycan structure can be
different among dimers of the glycoprotein hormone family. In hCG, the
COOH-terminal peptide (CTP) has been also shown to affect the core
mannosyl unit of the
-subunit, resulting in complex forms at both
N-glycosylation sites (133). Noteworthy, outer
glycosylation was achieved through polylactosamine units rather than
sialic acid when the heterodimer lacking CTP was expressed in CHO
cells. This and other studies (116) indicate that
polypeptide folding affects carbohydrate processing resulting in
distinct oligosaccharide patterns among closely related glycoprotein hormones.
2. Biological activity
Over the past years, extensive work of several groups explored the
glycosylation patterns at individual glycosylation sites using
site-directed mutagenesis and different host cells. Recombinant TSH
produced in CHO cells is sialylated and not sulfated because these
cells lack the two enzymes (GalNAc- and sulfo-transferase) involved in
addition of the terminal sulfated GalNAc residues. Expressing the
wild-type hormone in CHO lectin-resistant cells (CHO-LEC2
cells) deficient in sialyltransferases (181-183) showed a
five- to eightfold higher activity than in parent cells able to
sialylate the heterodimer, and this was not further augmented by
site-specific deglycosylation (67). TSH with
incomplete glycans retained full receptor binding while exhibiting
increased signal transduction, demonstrating that sialic acid
attenuates receptor activation. Differences could also been noticed
upon expression of the wild-type dimer in different host cells,
suggesting again that TSH glycoforms can further differ in activity
probably on the basis of the underlying glycan structure. Deleting the
glycosylation sites by Asn to Gln mutation revealed that the hormone
lacking Asn-52 displayed a sixfold increase in the in vitro activity, whereas activities of
N78Q/TSH
and
/TSH
N23Q were only
increased by a factor of 2-3 (67). These findings show
that the presence of each glycan is crucial to attenuate intrinsic TSH
activity, probably through a conformational effect on functional
domains. These observations suggest that modulation of TSH bioactivity is dependent on the glycosylation site, the extent of oligosaccharide branching, and the oligosaccharide termini. Interestingly, it was noted
that sialylation of the oligosaccharide at Asn-52 specifically attenuated intrinsic TSH activity in contrast to the previously reported stimulatory role in hCG (158) and FSH
(210). Altogether, these studies further emphasize the
role of individual glycans in modulating signal transduction and
hormone-specific effects of sialic acid residues.
3. Metabolic clearance
As rhTSH has been recently used for thyroid cancer imaging, it was
essential to estimate the effect of glycosylation on in vivo biological
activity of the drug. Structure-function studies were performed to
delineate the molecular determinants of metabolic clearance of rhTSH to
select optimal preparations in vivo. An initial finding was that
carbohydrate-mediated effect on rhTSH clearance is largely based on
sialic acid capping (202). rhTSH with decreased
sialylation is rapidly cleared from the circulation by the hepatic
asialoglycoprotein receptor while highly sialylated hormone displayed
prolonged plasma half-life (193). Sulfated forms of
pituitary TSH can be cleared through a specific hepatic lectin
(53) while the presence of sialic acid increases their duration in blood and limit clearance by the kidneys
(194). Therefore, a variable sulfate-to-sialic acid ratio
may be considered as a structural fine-tuning of the amount of TSH
that can reach the thyroid under physiological conditions. Importantly,
it was demonstrated that glycan structure affects in vitro and in vivo
TSH bioactivity in opposite directions (193,
195). Although asialo-rhTSH has a 5- to 10-fold
increased in vitro activity, it has also the shortest plasma
half-life in vivo. Similarly, rhTSH produced in insect cells
containing mannose-rich glycans was found to be of high activity
but displayed a rapid clearance because it was eliminated through a
mannose-specific receptor. Studies by Simpson et al. (178) indicated that SO4-4GalNAc-containing LH
and TSH bind to the NH2-terminal cysteine-rich domain
of the macrophage mannose receptor, distinct from the mannose binding
site. Thus sialic acid and its derivatives thus appeared optimal
terminal sugar candidates to create long-lasting glycoforms of
rhTSH drug. To this end, sialylation at different sites may affect
hormonal clearance to a different degree. It was shown that the
peripherally located carbohydrate chain of the TSH
-subunit at the
Asn-23 appears the most important in determining the clearance rate of
TSH (195). In the
-subunit, the Asn-78 glycan is more
critical than that attached to Asn-52 (67). Again,
variable terminal residues at each position may determine individual
clearance parameters of each TSH glycoform.
E. Alterations of TSH Carbohydrates Structures in Pathophysiology
Circulating TSH should be considered as being composed of a panel of forms differing in glycan structure, released by the pituitary under hypothalamic stimulation and/or thyroid status, and cleared according to their individual metabolic rate. As a result, it is now widely admitted that structural microheterogeneity of plasma TSH can reflect the status of the whole endocrine axis. This mechanism provides to the pituitary-thyroid balance an enormous potential to adapt to physiological needs by regulating both the quality and the amount of TSH with a combinatorial flexibility, which has not been easy to decipher experimentally. It was first observed that distribution of pituitary rat TSH was modified in primary hypothyroidism, suggesting a selective release of hormonal forms with altered glycosylation (74). In hypothyroid patients, plasma TSH glycoforms appeared mostly acidic with an increased sialic acid content due to a shift to higher glycan branching (148). This observation has been confirmed more recently since differences could be measured between subclinical and overt hypothyroidism. TSH from patients with subclinical hypothyroidism displayed increased core-fucosylation and a moderately augmented content in sialic acid compared with euthyroid TSH (206). More overt hypothyroidism gradually results in a more pronounced increase in sialic acid (increased branching or shift in terminal capping), suggesting that as thyroid dysfunction is accentuated, low active glycoforms with prolonged half-time are selectively released by the pituitary to stimulate the TSHR. Indeed, TRH was found capable of releasing such acidic forms from TSH-secreting adenomas (175), indicating a selective discrimination of the pituitary stock upon secretion. Very recently, sera obtained from euthyroid volunteers before and 30, 60, 120, 180, and 240 min after intravenous, nasal, and oral administration of TSH were found to contain increased acidic forms as a function of time (171). Lectin analysis confirmed a concomitant increase in core-fucosylated glycans. Overall, these findings point to a tight endocrine regulation of TSH polymorphism based on structural changes in core branching as well as outer glycosylation that probably accounts for altered B/I ratio. It is expected that the understanding of such molecular changes will help to design new TSH immunoassays to better assess plasma levels especially in detecting early subclinical hypothyroidism.
As described above, terminal carbohydrate residues can affect plasma
half-life and in vivo bioactivity of TSH through an interaction with specific hepatic carbohydrate receptors. It is therefore not
surprising that the distribution of hTSH glycoforms is under endocrine
control and is altered in various states of thyroid dysfunction. hTSH
glycosylation isoforms with higher bioactivity have been reported in
patients with resistance to thyroid hormone (9). Variable
carbohydrate structures of circulating TSH have also been described in
TSH-secreting pituitary adenomas and central (hypothalamic)
hypothyroidism and have also been associated with the euthyroid sick
syndrome, chronic uremia, TRH/octreotide administration, cranial
irradiation, intrauterine stage, and aging (8,
9, 70). Such regulation of hTSH glycosylation
may be viewed largely as an adaptive response, thus contributing to the
classical negative triiodothyronine (T3)/thyroxine
(T4)-TSH-TRH feedback loop. The evidence exists that TRH
enhances the biologic activity of TSH by modifying its glycosylation
pattern (199, 200, 228). In primary hypothyroidism, pituitary compensation would not only result in
an increased hormone production and secretion, but the released TSH
would have an altered carbohydrate structure that prolongs its plasma
half-life. At the molecular level, this may involve a direct
regulation of the transcription of glycosyltransferases by thyroid
hormone, as, for example, thyroid hormone status has been shown to
modulate
2,3- and
2,6-sialyltransferase mRNA levels in mouse
thyrotrophs (81). It has been shown that in patients with
central hypothyroidism and "abnormally normal" or slightly elevated
TSH levels, TSH lacks its bioactivity owing to an altered glycosylation
pattern. Such patients thought to suffer from hypothalamic TRH
deficiency are shown to benefit from chronic TRH administration, which
was found to increase TSH bioactivity and subsequently circulating thyroid hormone level in some patients (7,
115).
| |
V. THYROID-STIMULATING HORMONE RECEPTOR AND THYROID-STIMULATING HORMONE-THYROID-STIMULATING HORMONE RECEPTOR INTERACTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The TSHR together with LH and FSH receptors are related members of
rhodopsin/
-adrenergic receptor family in the seven-transmembrane domain, GPCR superfamily. The TSHR is critical in the development, growth, and function of the thyroid. In contrast to many other subfamilies of GPCRs, the TSHR and other glycoprotein hormone receptors
contain a large 300- to 400-amino acid-long extracellular domain
with at least 8 highly conserved Cys residues, involved in formation of
extracellular domain tertiary structure that appears important in both
ligand binding and inactive receptor conformation. Only selected
particularly new aspects of TSHR are discussed here. Several other
aspects of TSHR studies, including its relation to Graves' disease,
are summarized in several comprehensive reviews (63,
97, 156, 159, 214,
229).
A. TSHR: Gene and Expression
The human TSHR gene is located on chromosome 14q31 (163). The extracellular domain is encoded by the first nine exons and part of the last exon, whereas the transmembrane and intracellular domains are encoded entirely by the last exon. In addition to the expression of the gene encoding this receptor in thyroid tissue, the presence of TSHR (mRNA transcripts and/or protein) has been described in several other sites including lymphocytes, adipocytes, retroocular fibroblasts, neuronal cells, and astrocytes (32, 63, 126, 150). The low-affinity TSH binding site, detected previously in bacteria, is considered an artifact (135). An initial indication of potential extrathyroidal action of TSH derived from early studies demonstrating the presence of TSHR in human lymphocytes (154). Expression of TSHR in lymphocytes has been supported by more recent studies and indicated a possibility of paracrine or autocrine regulation by TSH (36). However, the physiological or pathophysiological relevance of such extrapituitary TSH secretion is not yet clear. Recently, additional data have supported possible functions of locally secreted hTSH. Specifically, there has been a description of the TRH-TSH network in the intestinal mucosa, suggesting that TSH produced by enterocytes may regulate function of intraepithelial lymphocytes as well as enterocytes by the TSHR-mediated mechanism (218). Interestingly, mice bearing a natural inactivating mutation in the TSHR display signs of impaired gastrointestinal immunity (184, 218). In addition, TSH has been recognized to mediate immunopotentializing effects of TRH and for the possible role of TSH-dependent interleukin-2 activation of cytotoxic lymphocytes in the course of thyroid autoimmune disorders (153). Recently, studies using TSHR knock-out mice indicated that TSH may serve as a negative regulator of osteoblast and osteoclast formation (117). Finally, the lipolytic effects of TSH have long been known and explained by the presence of low level of TSHR in adipocytes (33, 46). However, it must be emphasized that it has not been unequivocally established whether functional TSHR protein is expressed in such tissues and/or whether the number of receptors expressed would be physiologically relevant.
There are two recent reports of isolation of TSHR cDNAs from nonmammalian vertebrates. Two thyrotropin receptor cDNAs (sTSHRa and sTSHRb) were recently cloned from thyroid tissue of the amago salmon (143). sTSHRa and sTSHRb showed a high degree of sequence homology to mammalian TSHRs. Functional characterization in COS-7 cells transiently transfected with sTSHRa or sTSHRb showed the largest increase in cAMP when exposed to bovine TSH, suggesting that the cloned cDNAs encode functional TSHR proteins. RT-PCR analysis demonstrated that sTSHRa and sTSHRb were expressed in the basibranchial region, but not in the ovary, testis, liver, kidney, or brain. In situ hybridization revealed that sTSHRa and sTSHRb were exclusively expressed in thyroid follicular epithelial cells (143). TSHR was also recently cloned from the gonads of a nonmammalian vertebrate, a bony fish [striped bass (stb)] (101). The striped bass TSHR (stbTSHR) transcripts were abundant in both the thyroid and gonads and detectable in skeletal muscle, heart, and brain tissues. The stbTSHR cDNA encoded a 779-amino acid glycoprotein hormone receptor with much higher homology (57-59%) to the mammalian TSHRs than to the gonadotropin receptors. It contains a TSHR-specific insertion in the extracellular domain as seen in mammalian TSHRs. Recombinant stbTSHR expressed in COS-1 cells activated reporter genes (luciferase) driven by either a cAMP response element or the c-fos promoter in response to bovine TSH, stbLH, or hCG, but not human FSH. In situ hybridization studies revealed the presence of stbTSHR transcripts in the gametes but not in the follicular cells (101). This pattern of expression suggested a direct, although unknown, role for TSH in fish gamete physiology.
B. TSHR Structure-Function Studies
The TSHR, lutropin receptor (LHR), and follitropin receptor (FSHR) are related members of the superfamily of GPCR. Together with newly discovered receptors (141) they are now classified in the leucine-rich repeats-containing GPCR (LGR) proteins (see below). Several recent reviews addressed various aspects of their structure-function relationships (44, 99, 156). We focus here only on selected aspects, including common and unique features of TSHR, constitutive activity, and naturally occurring TSHR mutations.
Similar to other glycoprotein hormone receptors, TSHR has a large
extracellular domain, accounting for about one-half the molecular
size of the receptor (96, 97,
159, 174). Studies using isolated
extracellular domain of TSHR and LHR have confirmed that extracellular
domain is sufficient for high-affinity hormone binding
(22, 34, 145, 173).
In addition, the crystallization of the porcine ribonuclease inhibitor,
the first structurally known protein with specific structural elements
termed leucine-rich repeats (LRRs) (95) paved the way
for the modeling of the extracellular domain of glycoprotein hormone
receptors, as these receptors also contain such LRRs (10,
90). The LRRs are encoded by separate exons, suggesting
that the TSHR gene has arisen by insertion of a DNA sequence encoding
repeated LRRs between the regions encoding the extracellular and the
transmembrane domains of a protoreceptor gene resembling the intronless
-adrenergic receptor genes (65). However, different
modeling studies suggested six to nine LRRs; each repeat contains
-sheet oriented toward the interior circumference of the
horseshoe-like tertiary structure, which is now considered to bind
the hormone molecule. In addition to the three glycoprotein hormone
receptors, such LRRs have been found in other homologous receptors,
including mammalian LGR-4, LGR-5, LGR-6, LGR-7, and LGRs in sea
anemone, fly, and snail (84, 100,
141).
There are several important functional differences between TSHR and other glycoprotein hormone receptors. First, TSHR is more frequently activated by gain-of-function mutations than gonadotropin receptors (212, 214). Second, TSHR is unique among glycoprotein hormone receptors in that some mature receptors on the cell surface are cleaved into two subunits (156, 159). Third, unlike the single-chain gonadotropin receptors, TSHR is considered to be "noisy," transducing a signal via adenylate cyclase even in the absence of ligand (17). Fourth, similar to the thrombin receptor, proteolytic degradation or small deletion in the extracellular domain of TSHR can lead to its activation (211, 234). Although the LH receptor seems to be activated by proteolytic enzymes as well (162), TSHR seems to be much more prone to such activation. Fifth, unlike many other GPCRs, including the FSHR where guanine nucleotides reduce agonist binding (235), TSH binding to TSHR did not change in the presence of a nonhydrolyzable GTP analog (3). Finally, our studies on hTSH superactive analogs, including analogs with multiple mutations, demonstrate that the increase in receptor binding activity and in vitro bioactivity is generally parallel (70, 107, 191), suggesting that there is no clear distinction between recognition and activation binding sites in the TSHR.
In contrast to the LH and FSH receptor, there are two unique insertions in the TSH primary structure. The first 8-amino acid insertion near the NH2 terminus (residues 38-45) was shown to be important for TSH and stimulating antibody binding (156, 216), whereas a second 50-amino acid residue insertion (residues 317-366) has no apparent effect on TSHR function. The cluster of four cysteine residues at positions 24, 29, 31, and 41 was recently shown to be involved in formation of highly conformational epitope for thyroid stimulating antibodies (23). Two highly conserved cysteines in extracellular loops 1 and 2 of TSHR are also predicted to form a disulfide bond as identified in bovine rhodopsin structure (147).
Posttranslational modifications of TSHR include glycosylation of six asparagine residues. However, substitution of Asn at positions 99, 177, 198, and 302 did not appreciably affect the affinity of the TSHR for TSH or its ability to mediate an increase in intracellular cAMP levels (166). In contrast, N-linked glycosylation of Asn-77 and Asn-113 does play a role in the expression of a biologically active TSHR on the cell surface. Other posttranslational modifications of TSHR may include amidation and tyrosine sulfation (see below). However, clearly unique is the existence of natural processing mechanism leading to the two-subunit structure with not yet clear functional significance (63, 156). Further characterization of a soluble bioactive NH2-terminal extracellular domain (29, 34) should ultimately result in the elucidation of structural basis of TSH recognition.
C. Naturally Occurring TSHR Mutations
Numerous mutations in the TSHR gene have been identified and associated with specific thyroid diseases (139, 151). Resistance to TSH is a syndrome due to reduced responsiveness of the thyroid gland to biologically active TSH. Inactivating mutations of the TSHR have been detected in several cases of resistance to TSH, both partial and complete, sporadic and familial. More than 10 different inactivating mutations have been described. Germline mutations inactivating TSHR may cause primary hypothyroidism due to TSH unresponsiveness.
There are more than 30 different activating mutations causing nonautoimmune hyperthyroidism. Toxic nodules are quite frequently caused by somatic mutations constitutively activating TSHR. Germline mutations activating TSHR explain pathophysiology of autosomal dominant nonautoimmune hyperthyroidism (50).
Constitutive receptor activity, i.e., signaling by receptors in the absence of ligand binding, has been described for numerous GPCRs. Constitutively active glycoprotein hormone receptors showed increased ligand affinity compared with the wild-type receptors (136). This may suggest that the receptor in an open constitutively active conformation may have exposed additional binding domain not present in the closed conformation (see below). Extracellular loops of transmembrane domain may form such a domain, fully accessible to the ligand only in certain active conformations. Although functional characterization of different activating mutations contributed to the identification of TSHR domain important for receptor binding and signal transduction, new insights into the mechanism of TSHR activation have been also provided using experimental site-directed mutagenesis, molecular modeling, synthetic peptides, and enzymatic and immunological approaches.
Recently, a family was described with a resistance to TSH responsible for euthyroid hyperthyrotropinemia in two siblings (165). A new mutation responsible for the Arg to Cys substitution at position 310, in the extracellular domain, has been described. When stably transfected in CHO cells, the Cys-310 TSHR mutant showed loss of response to TSH. However, increased constitutive activity assessed based on cAMP production explained the presence of TSH resistance with the clinical euthyroidism detected in this family (165).
D. Suppressive Effect of Extracellular Domain: The "Two-State" Model
As described above, the TSHR is much more susceptible than other
glycoprotein hormone receptors to constitutive activation by mutations,
deletions, or even mild trypsin digestion (211). In our
study, constitutive activity has been demonstrated for the first time
for truncated TSHR lacking 98% of the extracellular domain
(233). The active state of truncated receptor with respect to Gs protein coupling and adenylate cyclase activation can
be suppressed at least in part by the presence of
-subunit linked to
the truncated receptor. In this study, the constitutive activity of the
TSHR missing 386 NH2-terminal amino acid residues was
normalized based on cell surface expression. Such normalized activity
of this deletion mutant was four to seven times higher than the
normalized constitutive activity of the wild-type TSHR, suggesting
that the extracellular domain of TSHR inhibits constitutive activity of the transmembrane domain. These findings provided important evidence supporting a two-state model of TSHR activation and suggest a potential role of proteolytic cleavage in receptor activation and
indicated new strategies for design of TSHR antagonists. The two-state model of receptor activation (92,
106) is illustrated with important modifications in Figure
6. According to this model adapted to the
TSHR (43), receptors are in equilibrium between the
inactive ("closed") conformation and a constitutively active ("opened") conformation that can associate with Gs in
the absence of hormone and trigger the intracellular signal. TSH
preferentially binds to opened receptors and stabilizes them. This
model is different from earlier models based on the assumption that
receptors require a hormone-induced conformational change. A major
prediction based on this model is that an agonist has a higher affinity
for the constitutively active (opened) conformation and that such an
active receptor conformation is stabilized by hormone binding. Although the essential concept of these models has not changed, there is now
more evidence suggesting that the equilibrium between active and
inactive states is not limited to two receptor states but include
multiple equilibria with a number of partially or full activated
states. Unlike previous models, our two-state model of TSHR
activation includes a possibility of the activating 409-418 region
present in the TSHR (see below). As depicted in Figure 6, ligand
binding will always lead to an opened conformation and receptor
activation. This can be prevented only by antagonists (inverse
agonists) capable of binding to the constitutively active ("opened") conformation and transforming it into an inactive
conformation. Because hormone binding is inherently associated with an
opened conformation, resembling the constitutively active unliganded conformation, simple site-specific modification of the ligand cannot result in a receptor antagonist. According to our model, the
mechanism of hormone-induced receptor activation is not only dependent on the elimination of inhibitory interactions between the
extracellular domain and extracellular loops of transmembrane domain,
recently supported by studies using LH receptor chimeras (142) and TSHR mutations in the hinge region
(83), but also may include an "activating region"
located in the extracellular domain near the first transmembrane helix,
which may function similar to the tethered ligand sequence in the
protease-activated receptors (PARs) (31). Similar
inhibitory constraints of extracellular domain released after
ligand binding have previously been described for insulin and other
CKGF receptors (236). Furthermore, our studies on
glycoprotein hormone superagonists highlight the concept that
glycoprotein hormone receptor activation is based, at least in part, on
electrostatic interactions between the hormone and the extracellular
domain of the receptor leading to the disruption of charge-based
silencing effect of extracellular domain. According to such a model,
activity of the unbound TSHR is kept at relatively low level by an
inhibitory interaction between the extracellular domain and the
transmembrane domain (43). A similar concept was proposed
for the thrombin receptor (137) based on findings that
alterations of extracellular domain and extracellular loops of
transmembrane domain may cause constitutive signaling. This model is
also supported by several other observations. First, constitutively
active receptors with mutations in different parts of extracellular
domain and extracellular loops of the transmembrane domain of human
TSHR are among the strongest activating mutations identified
(43); both domains were previously found to contribute to
TSHR ligand binding and signaling. In addition, numero